Symmetry Breaking |

**In Quantum Theory**
> s.a. modified lorentz symmetry.

* __Idea__: A quantum theory may break
symmetries that hold classically, either at the level of the theory itself or its
solutions (the latter is spontaneous symmetry breaking, see below), and then some
symmetries are lost, or may replace the symmetry group by a deformed one.

@ __References__:
Amelino-Camelia gq/02-conf [quantum spacetime];
van Wezel & van den Brink AJP(07)jul [simple procedure];
Baker PhSc(11)jan [and spacetime];
Landsman SHPMP(13)-a1305.

**Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking in Field Theory**
> s.a. critical phenomena; Mermin-Wagner
Theorem; phase transitions; vector fields.

* __Idea__: Suppose we have a Lagrangian
density \(\cal L\) which is invariant under a certain Lie group of transformations
*G*; We say that the symmetry group *G* is broken to a subgroup
*G*/*H* if the ground state of the theory is only invariant under
the action of *G*/*H*; It will then also be degenerate, the subgroup
*H* taking one vacuum into another.

* __Rem__: It must be then that the
symmetry group *G* is not implementable by operators that establish the
unitary equivalence between representations; Rather, the unitary operator that
implements the symmetry (by Wigner's theorem) connects the folia of unitarily
inequivalent representations.

* __Mechanism__: The way this usually
happens is that the potential *V* in \(\cal L\) contains a parameter, say
*m*, such that for some values of *m* the ground state has the same
symmetries as \(\cal L\), and for some others it does not; if at high temperatures
the effective potential *V* has a vacuum with symmetry group *G* and
at low temperatures one with symmetry group \(G/H\), as the system cools it may stay
for some time in the symmetric, false vacuum, and then decay to the less symmetric,
true vacuum.

* __Symmetry restoring__: It can be
usually achieved by adding energy to the system, through a phase transition.

* __Restrictions__: It cannot occur in
1+1 dimensions, since in this case there is no well-posed theory of a massless
scalar field.

@ __General references__:
Cianciaruso et al a1408,
a1604 [classical nature of ordered phases];
Heissenberg & Strocchi a1906 [generalized criterion].

@ __Vacuum decay__:
Beckwith mp/04 [by tunneling Hamiltonian];
Czech PLB(12)-a1112 [by "barnacle" instability];
Mohamadnejad a1709;
> s.a. vacuum.

**Nambu-Goldstone Bosons / Theorem** > s.a. higgs mechanism.

* __Idea__: Every generator of a
spontaneously broken Lie symmetry group *G* \(\mapsto) *G*/*H*
gives rise to a collective boson excitation, a (Nambu-)Goldstone mode described by
a field with values in *G*/*H*, or a massless particle called a
Goldstone boson.

* __Conditions__: A spontaneous
symmetry breaking gives rise to Goldstone bosons only in the case of a global
symmetry breaking; In the gauge symmetry case the degenerate directions are
gauge and don't correspond to physical modes; Both types however give rise
to topological defects.

@ __General references__: Goldstone NC(61);
Goldstone, Salam & Weinberg PR(62);
Burgess ht/98-ln [primer],
PRP(00)ht/98 [nuclear, particle and condensed-matter physics];
Chodos & Gallatin JMP(01)mp/00;
Smeenk PhSc(07)dec [meaning of breaking of gauge symmetry];
Guralnik MPLA(11)-a1107 [and gauge invariance];
Friederich EJPS-a1107 [breaking of gauge symmetry];
Kartavtsev a1404-wd [proof revisited];
Arraut IJMPA(17)-a1803 [origin of mass].

@ __Known particles__: Bjorken ht/01-conf [photon];
Kraus & Tomboulis PRD(02)ht [photon and graviton, Lorentz symmetry].

@ __Spacetime symmetries__: Low & Manohar PRL(02)ht/01;
Kobayashi & Nitta PRL(14)-a1402 [and internal symmetries].

@ __In 1+1 dimensions__: Coleman CMP(73);
Faber & Ivanov ht/02;
Balachandran & Immirzi IJMPA(03)ht/02 [fuzzy].

@ __Related topics__:
Strocchi PLA(00) [classical counterpart];
Bluhm & Kostelecký PRD(05)ht/04,
Berezhiani & Kancheli a0808 [for breaking of Lorentzian symmetry];
Watanabe et al PRL(13)-a1303 [massive Nambu-Goldstone bosons];
news ns(14) sep [observation in superconductors].

**Models and Examples** > s.a. decoherence;
effective quantum field theory; electroweak
theory; mass [origin]; Peccei-Quinn Mechanism.

* __Applications__: Used in unified
theories of fields in the early universe; Can lead to inflation.

* __Models__: To write down a
phenomenological model that realizes a spontaneous symmetry breaking, it is
convenient to choose a field valued in the new vacuum; e.g., an SU(2)-valued
field in the SU(2) × SU(2) \(\mapsto\) SU(2) *σ*-model;
One uses normally a spacetime scalar to break the symmetry, so that the
vacuum expectation value will not break Poincaré invariance.

* __Of Lorentz symmetry__: It could
arise in a theory with non-vanishing vacuum expectation values of vector fields.

* __Physical examples__: Crystals;
Rotational levels of a deformed nucleus; The most deeply bound states of hadrons;
Ferromagnets.

* __Specific model__: Consider the Lagrangian

\(\cal L\) = (∂_{a}*φ*)
(∂^{a}*φ**)
− *m*^{2}*φφ**
− *λ* (*φφ**)^{2} .

which has a global U(1) symmetry *φ*(*x*) \(\mapsto\) exp{i*θ*}
*φ*(*x*); For *m*^{2} ≥ 0,
the ground state is also symmetric with respect to U(1) transformations, while, for
*m* < 0, the U(1) symmetry is spontaneously broken.

@ __General references__: Cho PRL(85);
Kerbrat et al RPMP(89) [electroweak, geometric];
Vachaspati hp/97-ln [early universe, rev];
Witten BAMS(07)
[applications to superconductors, four-manifold theory, and particle physics];
Rabinovici LNP(08)-a0708 [spacetime symmetries];
Jona-Lasinio PTP(10)-a1010.

@ __Lorentz group__: Yokoi PLB(01)ht/00 [2+1];
Chkareuli et al NPB(01) [non-observability, and symmetry generation].

@ __Diffeomorphism group__: Giddings PLB(91);
Requardt a1203 [with gravitons as Goldstone modes];
Lin & Labun JHEP(16)-a1501 [low-energy effective theory];
Bluhm a1601-MG14
[gravity theories with background fields];
> s.a. Effective Field Theory;
Induced Gravity.

@ __And gravity__: Ashtekar GRG(78) [due to gravitational interaction];
Helesfai CQG(08)-a0806 [in loop quantum gravity];
Meierovich JETP(09)-a0910 [2 extra dimensions, vector order parameter],
PRD(10) [vector order parameter, covariant equations];
Wise JPCS(12)-a1112 [spontaneous breaking of Lorentz symmetry by an observer and Hamiltonian gravity];
Krasnov PRD(12)-a1112;
> s.a. conformal gravity.

@ __Finite quantum systems__:
Birman et al PRP(13);
Wallace a1808 [decoherent-histories approach].

@ __Other examples__: Girotti et al PRD(03)ht/02 [non-commutative field theory];
Cseh & Tímár JPA(06)
[2D interacting boson model, kinematics vs dynamics];
Petersen et al JHEP(09)-a0907
[U(1)^{N} theories, patterns of remnant discrete symmetries];
Muñoz et al a1111
[classical model for spontaneous symmetry breaking];
Muñoz et al AJP(12)oct-a1205 [toy model];
Odagiri FP(14) [dilatation symmetry breaking
and standard model gauge couplings];
Yoshimura PTEP(16)-a1604 [lepton-number violation];
Dong et al CTP(17)-a1609 [many-body systems, quantitative];
Hill a1803-conf
[inertial symmetry breaking of Weyl-invariant theories];
> s.a. Chiral Symmetry; conformal symmetry;
crystals [time crystals]; inflationary
scenarios; PT Symmetry; Scale Invariance;
supersymmetry; Time-Reversal Symmetry
Violation; topological defects.

**References**

@ __Pedagogical intros, reviews__:
Crone & Sher AJP(91)jan;
Haft ht/97;
Tsou ht/98-conf;
Bernstein AJP(11)jan [and Higgs mechanism];
Strocchi a1201 [Scholarpedia];
Hamilton a1512-ln [for mathematicians];
Beekman et al a1909-ln.

@ __Historical__:
Brout & Englert ht/98-conf;
Straumann hp/98-in [including elasticity and hydrodynamics];
Brout ht/02-conf;
Englert ht/02-conf,
ht/04-conf;
Shirkov PU(09)-a0903,
MPLA(09);
Guralnik IJMPA(09)-a0907,
a1110-proc;
Sardella a1012/NCC [spontaneous breaking].

@ __General__: Nambu PRL(60);
Nambu & Jona-Lasinio PR(61),
PR(61);
Abud & Sartori AP(83) [geometrical, classification];
Coleman 85;
Giddings & Wilczek MPLA(90);
Fujita et al ht/04 [criticism of Nambu & Jona-Lasinio];
Liu & Emch SHPMP(05) [2 accounts];
Fujita et al ht/05 [in quantum field theory, reinterpretation];
Birtea et al IJGMP(06);
Pérez & Sudarsky IJMPA(11)-a0811 [symmetries of the vacuum];
Nambu IJMPA(09);
Jona-Lasinio PTPS(10)-a1003-conf [conceptual, as analogy];
Baker & Halvorson SHPMP(13)-a1103 [unitarily inequivalent representations and unitary operators];
Fraser PhSc(12)
[conceptual, quantum statistical mechanics vs quantum field theory];
Hamma et al PRA(16)-a1501 [and quantum mutual information];
Becchi a1607 [renormalizable theories].

@ __Non-perturbative__: Bender & Milton PRD(97)ht/96;
Dzhunushaliev FPL(03)ht/02;
Strocchi 05.

@ __Michel's theorem__: Michel CRAS(71);
Gaeta & Morando AP(97)mp/02.

@ __Related topics__:
Gaeta PRP(90) [and bifurcation];
D'Hoker & Weinberg PRD(94)hp [effective actions];
Lepora JHEP(99) [geometry of vacuum];
Tomasello et al EPL(11)-a1012 [and quantum correlations];
Bogoslovsky IJGMP-a1201 [phase transitions and Finslerian event space];
> s.a. Emergence.

main page
– abbreviations
– journals – comments
– other sites – acknowledgements

send feedback and suggestions to bombelli at olemiss.edu – modified 14 sep 2019