Phenomenology of Higher-Order Gravity Theories  

Solutions > s.a. Birkhoff's Theorem; schwarzschild; wormholes.
* In general: All solutions of the ordinary Einstein equation still extremize S, and there are other solutions; However, if S does not include the usual R term, the ordinary solutions do not couple to positive-definite matter sources.
* Features: In some theories, torsion and its conjugate momentum play an important role.
* Results: Birkhoff's theorem in general is not valid, but it is in some cases; There is massive radiation (2 Yukawa potentials, 8 degrees of freedom, the usual spin-2 graviton, a massive one – negative energy – and one scalar field); It is claimed that in theories with purely quadratic terms in the action, the energy is identically zero, but this seems strange (RDS).
@ Gravitational waves: Campanelli & Loustó PRD(96)gq/95 [shock waves]; de Rey et al CQG(03)gq, CQG(03)gq, CQG(04)gq/03; Ananda et al PRD(08)-a0708 [4th-order gravity in FRW]; Corda a0710-in [R–1 theory]; > s.a. gravitational wave background.
@ Types of solutions: Campanelli et al PRD(94)gq [perturbative method]; Barraco & Hamity GRG(99) [asymptotically flat, and general relativity solutions]; Clifton & Barrow PRD(05)gq [Gödel, Einstein and de Sitter], CQG(06) [Kasner-type], CQG(06)gq [cosmological, 4th-order theories]; Goswami et al a0804 [Einstein universes, 4th-order theories]; > s.a. spherical symmetry.

Cosmology > s.a. acceleration; expansion; cmb; friedmann equation; FRW spacetime; Gauss-Bonnet Gravity; higher-order gravity.
* Cosmic no hair theorem: Within fourth order gravity with L = R + R2, the inflationary phase turns out to be a transient attractor.
* R–1 theories: They lead to cosmological acceleration, which is part of their motivation; A 1/R term by itself is ruled out by constraints on scalar-tensor gravity, but could work as an extra contribution to the action.
@ R2 theories: Cárdenas et al MPLA(03)gq [and inflation]; Meng & Wang GRG(04), CQG(05)gq/04, GRG(05) [Palatini, and inflation]; Debnath & Paul IJMPD(06)gq/05 [varying G and cosmological constant].
@ R–1 theories: Nojiri & Odintsov PRD(03)ht [inflation & acceleration]; Meng & Wang CQG(03)ap; Mena et al PRL(06)ap/05 [and supernovas; news pw(06)feb]; Poplawski CQG(06)gq/05 [acceleration], CQG(06)gq/05 [present and late universe]; PLB(06)gq [jerk parameter]; DeDeo et al a0712-PRL [stable accelerating universe from f(R) = R 4/R].
@ ln R theories: Nojiri & Odintsov GRG(04)ht/03 [and acceleration].
@ Arbitrary f(R): Carroll et al PRD(05)ap/04; Zhang PRD(06)ap/05 [large-scale structure]; Sotiriou CQG(06)gq/05 [positive and negative powers of R]; Carloni et al CQG(06) [bounce conditions]; Poplawski PRD(06)gq [and dark energy]; Brookfield et al PRD(06)ht [trinomial in R, cosmology and 5th force]; Fay et al PRD(07)ap; Li & Barrow PRD(07)gq [metric]; Zhang PRD(07)ap [solar system + galaxies]; Fay et al PRD(07)gq, Appleby & Battye PLB(07)-a0705 [and CDM cosmology]; Rahvar & Sobouti a0704-PRL [f from acceleration]; Koivisto a0706 [Palatini + generalized dark matter]; De Felice et al PRD(08)-a0706 [bounds on parameters]; Starobinsky JETPL(07)-a0706 [effective cosmological constant in some solutions]; Song et al PRD(07)-a0706 [acceleration and cmb].
@ f(R) theories, expansion and acceleration: Samart ap/06; de la Cruz-Dombriz & Dobado PRD(06)gq; Amendola et al PRL(07)ap/06, IJMPD(07)ap/06, PRD(07) [ruled out by wrong expansion rate]; Rador PRD(07)ht; Nojiri et al a0705-PLB [f(R)-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet]; Cognola et al PRD(08)-a0712; Lee a0801-MPLA; Nojiri & Odintsov a0801-in [dark matter, dark energy and inflation]; Appleby & Battye JCAP(08)-a0803; Carvalho et al a0804.
@ Ricci-squared theories: Allemandi et al PRD(04)ht [Rab Rab lagrangians]; Li et al PRD(07)-a0707 [R + f(Rab Rab)]; Cotsakis & Tsokaros PLB(07) [radiation-dominated, flat FRW].
@ Singularities: Middleton & Barrow PRD(08)-a0801 [isotropic singularity, stability]; Höffer von Loewenfeld & Sachs a0803 [resolution].
@ Other cosmology: Brüning et al GRG(94)gq [non-analytic, and inflation]; Fukuma et al PTP(01)ht [AdS-cft]; Ezawa et al CQG(03)gq; Carloni et al CQG(05)gq/04 [Rn]; Comelli & Dolgov JHEP(04) [determinant gravity]; Lambiase & Scarpetta PRD(06)ap [baryogenesis]; De Felice & Hindmarsh JCAP(07)-a0705 [unsuccessful class of theories]; Abdelwahab et al CQG(08)-a0706 [exp{–R/} gravity]; > s.a. bianchi models; cosmological perturbations.

Other Phenomenology > s.a. black hole formation, laws and solutions; phenomenology of gravity; tests of general relativity.
* Stability: Certain f(R) theories can stabilize solutions which are unstable in general relativity, such as the Einstein static universe.
@ General references: Capozziello & Francaviglia GRG(08) [rev].
@ Stability: Schmidt PRD(94); Ezawa et al CQG(99) [higher-dimensional, semiclassical]; Dolgov & Kawasaki ap/03 [R–1 theories]; De Felice et al JCAP(06)ap [superluminal mode propagation]; Faraoni PRD(06)ap, Sotiriou PLB(07)gq/06, Sawicki & Hu PRD(07)ap [f(R) theories]; Sokolowski CQG(07)gq [interpretation and viability]; Böhmer et al PRD(07)-a0706 [Einstein static universe]; Lee a0710.
@ Galactic dynamics: Capozziello et al PLA(04), ap/04-in, Frigerio & Salucci ap/07/MNRAS [rotation curves]; Borowiec et al ap/06-in [dark matter and dark energy].
@ Solar system constraints: Olmo PRL(05)gq, PRD(05)gq + gq, Jin et al gq/06 [f(R)]; Faraoni PRD(06)gq; Ruggiero & Iorio JCAP(07)gq/06 [planetary orbits]; Chiba et al PRD(07)ap/06; Zakharov et al PRD(06); Faulkner et al PRD(07)ap/06, Saffari & Rahvar PRD(08)-a0708 [and cosmology]; Hu a0705 [models that evade solar system tests]; Allemandi & Ruggiero GRG(07); Bertolami & Paramos a0709; Iorio & Ruggiero a0711; Capozziello & Tsujikawa PRD-a0712.
@ R–1 theories: Flanagan PRL(04)ap/03, Vollick CQG(04)gq/03, Kremer & Alves PRD(04)gq [Palatini form]; Soussa & Woodard GRG(04)ap/03 [force of gravity]; Vollick PRD(05)gq/04 [with Dirac field]; Shao et al PLB(06)gq/05 [as correction term]; Erickcek et al PRD(06)ap [ruled out by solar system tests].
@ Other theories: Clifton & Barrow PRD(05)gq [R1+a Lagrangian]; Navarro & Van Acoleyen JCAP(06)ap [ln f(R), dark energy and MOND].
@ Newtonian limit: Quandt & Schmidt AN(91)gq/01; Domínguez & Barraco PRD(04)gq [Palatini]; Capozziello gq/04-in [rev]; Capozziello & Troisi PRD(05)ap [4th-order, PPN limit]; Sotiriou GRG(06)gq/05; Bertolami et al PRD(07)-a0704 [extra force]; Capozziello et al PRD(07)-a0708.
@ Newtonian limit, R–1: Dick GRG(04)gq/03; Rajaraman ap/03; Navarro & Van Acoleyen PLB(05)gq [and acceleration]; Cembranos PRD(06)gq/05 [as lim at intermediate energy]; Navarro & Van Acoleyen JCAP(06)gq/05 [large distance].
@ Post-Newtonian framework: Allemandi et al GRG(05); Capozziello et al gq/06 [and experimental constraints].
@ Star interiors in f(R) gravity: Kainulainen et al PRD(07)-gq/06; Bustelo & Barraco gq/06/CQG; Henttunen et al PRD(08)-a0705.
@ Singularities: Holdom PRD(02) [and horizons]; > s.a. types of singularities [isotropic].
@ Related topics: Accioly et al NCB(00), Accioly & Blas PRD(01)gq [light deflection, quadratic]; Magnano & Sokolowski AP(03)gq/02 [massive spin-2 field generated]; Núñez & Solganik PLB(05)ht/04 [IR modifications not viable]; Gabadadze & Iglesias PLB(06) [precession]; Capozziello et al MPLA(07) [gravitational wave background]; Iorio & Ruggiero IJMPA(07) [double pulsar]; Li et al a0801 [indistinguishable macroscopic behavior]; > s.a. Chameleon Field; energy conditions; equivalence principle; gravitational radiation; thermodynamics.


Main pageAbbreviationsJournalsCommentsOther sitesAcknowledgements
Send feedback and suggestions to bombelli at olemiss.edu – Modified 22 jun 2008